Spider Lake Motel ~ Teal Lake Cottage ~ The Lookout


Featured properties

Stay at our newly built Lookout

After renovating nearly a dozen cabins in the Hayward area we finally got a chance to build one from the ground up in 2023. This was our favorite project thus far. We were inspired by our trip to Glacier National Park and all of their historical lodges. The Lookout is tucked into the Chequamegon National Forest and overlooks beautiful Teal Lake. Come and be wowed.

The Spider Lake Motel & Suites

Completely Renovated and Fashionably Updated. Spider Lake Motel is strategically located in the heart of the Chequamegon National Forest just a short drive to so many of the greatest fishing lakes the Hayward area has to offer. Spider Lake Motel is on the #5 Snowmobile Trail. Tiny’s Cafe and Dow’s Corner Bar are within walking distance and the Happy Hooker Bait and Convenience Store is a 1/4 mile away.

Teal Lake Cottage

We fell in love with the nostalgic 1930's lake home the minute we saw it. Out Teal Lake Cottage was one of the first built on the lake and therefore offers a grand lot which shelters you from any feel of a neighbor. The Cottage has tasteful updates and boasts 7 bedrooms and 4 baths with wonderful areas to gather or hide away. Our "Speakeasy" in the basement has a prohibition bar and all the big games to entertain young and old. Teal Lake Cottage is truly where the family memories are made. 

John and Liz are ranked "exceptional" hosts on vrbo with 100 reviews and a 4.9/5 star rating

5/5 Excellent

Lisa B.

Jun 21, 2023Liked: Cleanliness, check-in, communication, location, listing accuracy

Simply amazing!!

This place was better than I could have imagined! It had everything we needed and more. All the room and amenities we needed inside for the days we couldn’t be outside due to the weather and great shoreline and area for the days we could be outside. I’ve been renting from VRBO for many years and this is definitely one of the best.

5/5 Excellent

angie A.

Feb 16, 2023Liked: Cleanliness, check-in, communication, location, listing accuracy

Nostalgic Time Capsule

We couldn’t have had a better place to celebrate my husband’s 50th birthday with our large family and friends. Be prepared to enter your grandparents lake lodge and be swept away with its vintage charm and nostalgic feels! No need to ever leave, it has everything and more for your stay! The kitchen was more than stocked with all the ‘things’ for food prep. The basement was better than any venue we could have found to gather and celebrate. The variety of games and things to do left us entertained until the late hours. All the bedrooms were furnished with quality beds and linens. So cozy and comfy. I couldn’t find anything negative to say about this property. John was great to communicate with a great host. If you’re considering this place, your search is done!

5/5 Excellent

Angie C.

Aug 11, 2022Liked: Cleanliness, check-in, communication, location, listing accuracy

Perfect for multiple families

Great, large home for multiple families. Nice yard, great swimming beach, and awesome downstairs with games to play. Beds were very comfortable. Appreciated having two refrigerators as well as enough seating for our whole group at meal time. The owner was easy to work with. There was a canoe and row boat to use as well as two docks. We enjoyed having dinner and exploring McNott Island one evening. We thoroughly enjoyed our time here and appreciate the owners sharing it with us. We will be back.

5/5 Excellent

Jim W.

Aug 8, 2022Liked: Cleanliness, check-in, communication, location, listing accuracy

Family, 3 generation annual gathering

Fabulous property with 7 bedrooms spread out over 3 floors. Great beach access with a 2 dock option. Rented a pontoon for the entire week and fished and toured Tesl Lake multiple times daily.